On December 4, 2025, former chief Robert Sinnott Jr. was taken into custody by Cape Coral SWAT agents, marking the beginning of a criminal investigation into allegations that he forced firefighters into non‑consensual sexual contact.
Sinnott, who served in various capacities—including chief—at the Silverton Volunteer Fire Company in Toms River, Ocean County, New Jersey, is accused of abusing his position during the 2022‑2023 period.
According to the New Jersey Attorney General’s Office, the alleged incidents occurred when Sinnott isolated firefighters at his Toms River residence, at the firehouse, or in other undisclosed locations.
During these encounters, officials say Sinnott would handcuff or otherwise restrain the victims while claiming the restraint was part of a training exercise.
After the restraints were applied, Sinnott allegedly forced the victims into sexual contact, and in some cases took photographs of the restrained individuals.
The arrest was preceded by a search of Sinnott’s home and vehicle, during which authorities seized evidence related to the alleged misconduct.
He is currently being held at the Lee County Jail in Florida, pending extradition to New Jersey where he faces charges of criminal sexual contact and official misconduct.
The New Jersey Attorney General’s Office confirmed the charges and stated that the investigation is ongoing.
Detective Brandon Mastropasqua and Detective Malikah Daniels have been assigned to the case and are available for tips from the public.
Individuals with information can contact the detectives at 609‑960‑3768 or 856‑414‑8855, or submit a tip by calling 1‑844‑OPIA‑TIP.
The case has drawn attention to the responsibilities of volunteer fire personnel and the importance of safeguarding against abuse of authority within community organizations.
As the legal process continues, the community awaits further developments and the outcome of the charges brought against Sinnott.
Key Takeaways
- Former chief Robert Sinnott Jr. arrested Dec 4, 2025 in Florida.
- Allegations cover 2022‑2023 incidents involving forced sexual contact with firefighters.
- Charges include criminal sexual contact and official misconduct; held at Lee County Jail pending extradition.
The investigation remains active as authorities work to bring the case to resolution.
